Specifically, First Aid Kit's cover of Simon and Garfunkel's version.
And leaving aside the irony of the fact that one of the standards of popular American folk rock was done better by a pair of Swedes, there's plenty to unpack.
Here's the original:
Here's the First Aid Kit version:
Comparing the cover to the original--which has been nearly universally acclaimed--spares the normal discussion about the content of the song, which is about a road trip across the U.S. in which Simon, because he wrote the song in the 1960s, is trying to make a grand statement about the American Condition.
First Aid Kit's version differs largely in two ways: vocal arrangement and dynamics, and I'd argue that it's superior in both.
The first is less important, and subjective. Simon and Garfunkel sing in unison for most of the song, and it gives a haunting effect I came to love while I was listening to the doubled vocal tracks that characterize Elliott Smith. It's fine. But if you've got two people singing--particularly if one of them isn't playing an instrument--my personal philosophy is that you ought to make the most out of it. Trade off lines or verses for textural contrast, or have harmony throughout. The Soderberg sisters have built a signature sound on doing just that, so I find their drive from Canada to New York more interesting than Simon and Garfunkel's. That's a personal preference to be sure, but it does offer them an outlet Simon and Garfunkel denied themselves: unison for effect.
Unison for lack of a better idea is boring. Unison in contrast to alternating leads and/or harmony is like taking a whiff of smelling salts, and First Aid Kit breaks it out for the most important line in the song.
Which brings up the most important difference between the two versions: When we get the big crescendo in the fourth verse.
The single greatest weapon in a songwriter/composer's arsenal is the crescendo. The final crescendo is the climax, the way of highlighting that this is what the whole song's about. It's Act 5, Scene 1. It's what moves you.
So let's talk about where the crescendo comes in, and what that represents.
For Simon and Garfunkel, it comes in midway through the fourth verse, on "Counting the cars on the New Jersey Turnpike" and climaxing on "They've all come to look for America," which is the memorable melodic and lyrical element to the song. Anyone who knows anything about Simon and Garfunkel would be able to sing that line for you.
First Aid Kit brings in the crescendo with the strings leading up the fourth verse, then climaxes at the start of the verse: " 'Kathy, I'm lost,' I said / Though I knew she was sleeping. / 'I'm empty and aching and I don't know why.' " We'd been through the verse three times before that, and each time it had been lilting and beautiful and, frankly, optimistic. But once Kathy's asleep--once we're in a place where there's nobody to look strong for--the motif turns urgent and pained and desperate.
Simon and Garfunkel's version emphasizes that Paul and Kathy have driven across the country and haven't found America, whatever that is, and neither has anyone else on the road--hence "They've all come to look for America." It's chasing an ideal that isn't there anymore, and they don't know how to continue.
First Aid Kit's version emphasizes that Paul's in deep, personal, existential pain. He can't pinpoint the source of it, and he doesn't feel comfortable talking about it, even to the person he supposedly loves and trusts the most, and even though it's destroying him. The trip across the country isn't about looking for an American ideal, it's about looking for something worth saving in himself and his relationship, and not being able to find that is an entirely different question.
The difference between the two speaks volumes. Paul Simon was born in the 1940s and wrote the song in the 1960s. It's Boomer Music, so the central problem is with how other people view something national and abstract. There's an ironic detachment to the lyrics, and for a song called "America," it says absolutely fuck-all about the country or the culture.
The Soderbergs--both born in the 1990s--take up the same text and see that the central problem is that the narrator has a vague sense that he's not whole, that he's not feeling something he was supposed to, that he was promised. That absence, though entirely emotional, is causing him deep, possibly fatal pain, and he's been conditioned not to mention it to anyone. That's a powerful, relatable internal conflict, and not mere impotent, vague, bullshit Boomer hand-waving.
Moving the crescendo up makes it a far more interesting story, and it says a hell of a lot more about America than the original.
Wednesday, July 8, 2015
Wednesday, December 17, 2014
Baumann's Top 8 Songs of 2014
Here are the eight songs from the past year that I personally liked most/thought were best/felt the most drawn to. This is a completely subjective list, though I tried to explain in more concrete terms why I liked each song. If you don't feel like reading all my bullshit, there's a Spotify playlist at the bottom of the post.
8) "Girls Chase Boys" by Ingrid Michaelson, from Lights Out
I feel like Ingrid Michaelson really ought to be in my wheelhouse--the solo female singer/songwriter aesthetic is kind of where I live musically right now, as you might guess from the rest of this list, or from my Spotify history, which I'm pretty sure at one point included 500 Brandi Carlile songs in a row. But I've never really liked Ingrid Michaelson, which I think is partly because her music doesn't get bandied about in the indie/alt-rock circles whose music tends to float my way, and partly because I never really forgave her for how bad the lyrics to "The Way I Am" are.
"Girls Chase Boys" is similarly subdued, and the lyrics paint a pretty straightforward picture of striding confidently out of a breakup. It is, however, a very meticulously-structured song that manages to spend so much of its time sparse and quiet that it builds a crescendo into the chorus without ever really raising its voice.
I'm a sucker for a good crescendo into the chorus, particularly when it builds not only in volume, but climbs melodically in steps, and I think that's what really sets this song apart for me. Or it could be the clapping in the background--I'm a sucker for background clapping too. Or maybe it's the fact that there wasn't a catchier chorus in popular music this year and I spent most of the summer whistling it to myself.
Or it could be that "Girls Chase Boys" features, in a gender-bending pastiche of Robert Palmer's "Simply Irresistible," probably the best music video of the year.
I don't know--I've got a much better handle on why I like the other seven songs on this list, so there's room to just throw my hands up and make room for something nice, fun and uncomplicated.
7) "Stay Gold" by First Aid Kit, from Stay Gold
One of the great regrets in my life is that I was born in New Jersey and not Tennessee or the Carolinas, and I've spent most of my life in various states of ersatz Southernism, from adopting "y'all" for the second-person plural to drinking bourbon to, more recently, getting really into certain strains of country music.
Because I'm only a poseur, I don't feel bamboozled in the slightest that the Soderberg sisters of First Aid Kit, who toured with Connor Oberst and fit in nicely with the latter-day Loretta Lynn-ish folk and country music I've started listening to recently, are not only not Southern or Midwestern, they're not American, and in fact, not even native English-speakers.
Nevertheless, a lot of the charm of First Aid Kit in general (and "Stay Gold" in particular) lies in the Soderbergs' voices. Most of the time, they're cruising along in persistent harmony (and with an evidently affected twang), which coincides with my view that everyone in a given band who can sing should sing for as much of the song as possible, in as many different harmonic and countermelodic parts as you can cram into the damn thing. Take a look at this studio video to fully appreciate how much music there is in a relatively quiet folk song--that's the best thing about it, particularly the line "What if I fall and can't bear to get up?" in the chorus--it fits perfectly in terms of number and stress of syllables, but it goes by very quickly, and it takes a while to physically get your mouth around all the consonants--it's exactly as much music as you can fit in the line without being inelegant or stilted, and not an ounce less.
6) "Best Friend" by Foster the People, from Supermodel
I can totally understand that, if after "Pumped Up Kicks," you never want to hear Foster the People again--I was okay with adding them to the list of bands I'd liked at first encounter, but whose music I'd grown out of by the time their second album came out, and whose first single was so inescapably overplayed as to render the band unlistenable thereafter.
But "Best Friend" won me back over. Here's why:
5) "A Song for Our Grandfathers" by Future Islands, from Singles
I actively disliked the now-famous Future Islands-on-Letterman performance. Sam Herring is blessed with a voice fit to turn sand into chocolate fondue, but I find a lot of his onstage antics annoying and distracting. But this song is a testament to the great things that can be accomplished when you stop fucking around and get down to producing the kind of soulgazing, neo-Springsteenian agrarian synthpop that TV on the Radio would make if TV on the Radio had grown up in Appalachia and were deeply, profoundly uncool.
I don't have much else to say on the subject, except that if this song were a movie, it'd star Robert Duvall and Matthew McConaughey and be directed by Richard Linklater and I'd see it on opening night.
4) "It Will End in Disaster" by White Sea, from In Cold Blood
So what I said earlier about liking solo female singer-songwriters...2014 featured new albums from Nickel Creek, Gaslight Anthem and TV on the Radio, all bands I'm predisposed to love, but In Cold Blood lapped the field as my album of the year. (This happened last year, when The National and Arcade Fire both put out new albums and I kind of shrugged.)
White Sea is Morgan Kibby, who plays keyboards in M83 when she's not demolishing city blocks with the power of her voice alone. I don't know what I expected from an M83 veteran, but it wasn't this.
I love power ballads. I fucking love power ballads, and Morgan Kibby has been touched by the God of Power Ballads, the deity that produced children out of wedlock by the hundreds of thousands between 1979 and 1989.
I wonder what it's like to be the person who can write and perform songs like this. I bet it sucks. I bet she gets up in the morning and makes a bowl of oatmeal, then puts it down the table, but suddenly the table turns into a piano, and when she opens up her mouth to eat it, Whitney Houston's voice comes out.
This is a seismic, balls-out record that sounds like an angel telling a story about a fire engine fucking a computer mainframe. It could've put three or four songs in the top eight. The only thing "It Will End in Disaster" has over "They Don't Know" and "Small December" is that the first half of the song is the high point in the album--I'm not sure it's the best song overall. Go listen to this album, then build a shrine in your home.
3) "Stay With Me" by Sam Smith, from In the Lonely Hour
Sam Smith has a silly haircut, but he sure can sing. This is by far the most popular song on the list, so I don't think I need to give it the hard sell. I will say that I've derived immense joy from singing along with this song in the car, the way I've done with the works of Celine Dion.
2) "Midnight Blues" by Cherlene, from Cherlene (Songs from the Series Archer)
I said earlier that White Sea's In Cold Blood was my favorite album of the year. No. 2? The joke country album from Archer. I swear to God.
When Archer had its season-long departure from espionage thriller/workplace comedy to...I don't know how to describe Season 5, but there are drugs, one of the ongoing plots was secretary/heiress Cheryl's burgeoning country music career. So the producers hired a few musicians and had them arrange covers of, among other things, Kenny Loggins' "Danger Zone," and a few originals, of which the highlight was "Midnight Blues."
"Midnight Blues" is an energetic, bourbon-swilling, bird-flipping adventure that begs you to roll the windows down and sing along as loud as you can. Or it would, except I drive a small Japanese sedan, and I feel like this song is best listened to in a 30-year-old Jeep Grand Wagoneer or something. It's got a drum part out of AC/DC's "Thunderstruck," guitars that remind me of The Eagles, and, in session-violinist-turned-lead-singer Jessy Lynn Mertens vocals that can make being stoned and lonely sound like more fun than I've had in years.
1) "NYE" by Missy Higgins, from Oz
It's a cover, so I don't know if it's cheating or not, but this is my favorite song of the year. Oz is (hey, look, another female solo singer-songwriter) Missy Higgins' set of covers of songs from her native Australia. The original version of NYE, by Perry Keyes, is fine, but it sounds like the Pixies fell asleep while covering a Counting Crows song.
This version is transformative. I discovered it sometime in November, and since then I've listened to it hundreds of times, often on repeat, and every time I reflexively do a little side-to-side head-bobbing dance like those twin babies in that viral video from a couple years back.
This song gives me a very specific feeling, that of wanting to be 17 years old and skating with friends on an outdoor ice rink somewhere, when I see a girl I don't know, go up and talk to her and end up experiencing true love for the first time.
So how do you propel an okay 90s indie rock song to these heights? You do three things. First, you get Missy Higgins to sing it, because I'd rather listen to her sharp, energetic voice than Keyes' Diet Grunge drone. This arrangement plays with rhythm of the lead vocal line in parts, and when, by the end of the song, she's dragging out the line "shut your eyes and breathe" a fraction of a beat behind the instrumentals, you feel like she's earned the ability to urge you to do something.
Second, you crank the tempo to make it fast enough to be danceable, or at least foot-tappable.
Third, you Disney the shit out of it. What does that mean? Well, the original was clean electric guitar and pretty standard four-piece rock setup. But this is a song about being young and enjoying yourself when you go out on the biggest party night of the year--there's got to be a little joy to it. So it starts with tambourine and a bouncing piano behind the first verse (switching from guitar to piano allows the chorus to climb the scale with every chord change the way open-fingering guitar doesn't), then adds something each time it crosses the start-finish line: Backing vocals for the first chorus, bells for the second verse, organ (or the most disciplined woodwind section ever) on the second chorus. Brass on the bridge, saxophones on the third verse, and then everything comes together on the final repeated chorus.
It's light, it's fun, it's a little juvenile, and that's fine, because it sounds and feels like a Christmas song in the best ways, and without any of the overplayed, Korean War-vintage bullshit that usually comes from such music. It's a magnificent song, and I want to host a New Year's party just so I can play it for other people for six hours in a row.
8) "Girls Chase Boys" by Ingrid Michaelson, from Lights Out
I feel like Ingrid Michaelson really ought to be in my wheelhouse--the solo female singer/songwriter aesthetic is kind of where I live musically right now, as you might guess from the rest of this list, or from my Spotify history, which I'm pretty sure at one point included 500 Brandi Carlile songs in a row. But I've never really liked Ingrid Michaelson, which I think is partly because her music doesn't get bandied about in the indie/alt-rock circles whose music tends to float my way, and partly because I never really forgave her for how bad the lyrics to "The Way I Am" are.
"Girls Chase Boys" is similarly subdued, and the lyrics paint a pretty straightforward picture of striding confidently out of a breakup. It is, however, a very meticulously-structured song that manages to spend so much of its time sparse and quiet that it builds a crescendo into the chorus without ever really raising its voice.
I'm a sucker for a good crescendo into the chorus, particularly when it builds not only in volume, but climbs melodically in steps, and I think that's what really sets this song apart for me. Or it could be the clapping in the background--I'm a sucker for background clapping too. Or maybe it's the fact that there wasn't a catchier chorus in popular music this year and I spent most of the summer whistling it to myself.
Or it could be that "Girls Chase Boys" features, in a gender-bending pastiche of Robert Palmer's "Simply Irresistible," probably the best music video of the year.
I don't know--I've got a much better handle on why I like the other seven songs on this list, so there's room to just throw my hands up and make room for something nice, fun and uncomplicated.
7) "Stay Gold" by First Aid Kit, from Stay Gold
One of the great regrets in my life is that I was born in New Jersey and not Tennessee or the Carolinas, and I've spent most of my life in various states of ersatz Southernism, from adopting "y'all" for the second-person plural to drinking bourbon to, more recently, getting really into certain strains of country music.
Because I'm only a poseur, I don't feel bamboozled in the slightest that the Soderberg sisters of First Aid Kit, who toured with Connor Oberst and fit in nicely with the latter-day Loretta Lynn-ish folk and country music I've started listening to recently, are not only not Southern or Midwestern, they're not American, and in fact, not even native English-speakers.
Nevertheless, a lot of the charm of First Aid Kit in general (and "Stay Gold" in particular) lies in the Soderbergs' voices. Most of the time, they're cruising along in persistent harmony (and with an evidently affected twang), which coincides with my view that everyone in a given band who can sing should sing for as much of the song as possible, in as many different harmonic and countermelodic parts as you can cram into the damn thing. Take a look at this studio video to fully appreciate how much music there is in a relatively quiet folk song--that's the best thing about it, particularly the line "What if I fall and can't bear to get up?" in the chorus--it fits perfectly in terms of number and stress of syllables, but it goes by very quickly, and it takes a while to physically get your mouth around all the consonants--it's exactly as much music as you can fit in the line without being inelegant or stilted, and not an ounce less.
6) "Best Friend" by Foster the People, from Supermodel
I can totally understand that, if after "Pumped Up Kicks," you never want to hear Foster the People again--I was okay with adding them to the list of bands I'd liked at first encounter, but whose music I'd grown out of by the time their second album came out, and whose first single was so inescapably overplayed as to render the band unlistenable thereafter.
But "Best Friend" won me back over. Here's why:
- It sits at the precise aesthetic midpoint between Black Kids and MGMT, and while I liked both of those bands more as an undergrad than I do now, that realization amused me so much I kept listening to the song.
- The song starts with the chorus, and the chorus starts with two pickup notes, which throw the entire enterprise off-balance from the start in a really fun way.
- Horns. I need more horns in my life. The trumpet, plus the discoish guitar in the chorus, makes you want to do a very specific kind of dance that just involves kicking your feet out sideways and headbanging.
- It includes a chorus of children, which I like because of how unabashedly cheesy it is.
- The prechorus climbs the melodic hill, then comes back down the other side, which I'm always on board with on its own, but it takes a slightly dissonant path. Everything about this song confounds expectations by half a beat or half a step, and you find yourself in a groove, but one that's been carved out with a jackhammer, and one that you have to dance along with a Skip-It attached to one ankle. Like if you don't dance, they're going to cut your foot off, and if you dance improperly they're going to cut your foot off, and if you dance properly they might cut your foot off anyway, because fuck it, what's proper anymore? It's very fun and entirely unafraid of being made uneasy.
5) "A Song for Our Grandfathers" by Future Islands, from Singles
I actively disliked the now-famous Future Islands-on-Letterman performance. Sam Herring is blessed with a voice fit to turn sand into chocolate fondue, but I find a lot of his onstage antics annoying and distracting. But this song is a testament to the great things that can be accomplished when you stop fucking around and get down to producing the kind of soulgazing, neo-Springsteenian agrarian synthpop that TV on the Radio would make if TV on the Radio had grown up in Appalachia and were deeply, profoundly uncool.
I don't have much else to say on the subject, except that if this song were a movie, it'd star Robert Duvall and Matthew McConaughey and be directed by Richard Linklater and I'd see it on opening night.
4) "It Will End in Disaster" by White Sea, from In Cold Blood
So what I said earlier about liking solo female singer-songwriters...2014 featured new albums from Nickel Creek, Gaslight Anthem and TV on the Radio, all bands I'm predisposed to love, but In Cold Blood lapped the field as my album of the year. (This happened last year, when The National and Arcade Fire both put out new albums and I kind of shrugged.)
White Sea is Morgan Kibby, who plays keyboards in M83 when she's not demolishing city blocks with the power of her voice alone. I don't know what I expected from an M83 veteran, but it wasn't this.
I love power ballads. I fucking love power ballads, and Morgan Kibby has been touched by the God of Power Ballads, the deity that produced children out of wedlock by the hundreds of thousands between 1979 and 1989.
I wonder what it's like to be the person who can write and perform songs like this. I bet it sucks. I bet she gets up in the morning and makes a bowl of oatmeal, then puts it down the table, but suddenly the table turns into a piano, and when she opens up her mouth to eat it, Whitney Houston's voice comes out.
This is a seismic, balls-out record that sounds like an angel telling a story about a fire engine fucking a computer mainframe. It could've put three or four songs in the top eight. The only thing "It Will End in Disaster" has over "They Don't Know" and "Small December" is that the first half of the song is the high point in the album--I'm not sure it's the best song overall. Go listen to this album, then build a shrine in your home.
3) "Stay With Me" by Sam Smith, from In the Lonely Hour
Sam Smith has a silly haircut, but he sure can sing. This is by far the most popular song on the list, so I don't think I need to give it the hard sell. I will say that I've derived immense joy from singing along with this song in the car, the way I've done with the works of Celine Dion.
2) "Midnight Blues" by Cherlene, from Cherlene (Songs from the Series Archer)
I said earlier that White Sea's In Cold Blood was my favorite album of the year. No. 2? The joke country album from Archer. I swear to God.
When Archer had its season-long departure from espionage thriller/workplace comedy to...I don't know how to describe Season 5, but there are drugs, one of the ongoing plots was secretary/heiress Cheryl's burgeoning country music career. So the producers hired a few musicians and had them arrange covers of, among other things, Kenny Loggins' "Danger Zone," and a few originals, of which the highlight was "Midnight Blues."
"Midnight Blues" is an energetic, bourbon-swilling, bird-flipping adventure that begs you to roll the windows down and sing along as loud as you can. Or it would, except I drive a small Japanese sedan, and I feel like this song is best listened to in a 30-year-old Jeep Grand Wagoneer or something. It's got a drum part out of AC/DC's "Thunderstruck," guitars that remind me of The Eagles, and, in session-violinist-turned-lead-singer Jessy Lynn Mertens vocals that can make being stoned and lonely sound like more fun than I've had in years.
1) "NYE" by Missy Higgins, from Oz
It's a cover, so I don't know if it's cheating or not, but this is my favorite song of the year. Oz is (hey, look, another female solo singer-songwriter) Missy Higgins' set of covers of songs from her native Australia. The original version of NYE, by Perry Keyes, is fine, but it sounds like the Pixies fell asleep while covering a Counting Crows song.
This version is transformative. I discovered it sometime in November, and since then I've listened to it hundreds of times, often on repeat, and every time I reflexively do a little side-to-side head-bobbing dance like those twin babies in that viral video from a couple years back.
This song gives me a very specific feeling, that of wanting to be 17 years old and skating with friends on an outdoor ice rink somewhere, when I see a girl I don't know, go up and talk to her and end up experiencing true love for the first time.
So how do you propel an okay 90s indie rock song to these heights? You do three things. First, you get Missy Higgins to sing it, because I'd rather listen to her sharp, energetic voice than Keyes' Diet Grunge drone. This arrangement plays with rhythm of the lead vocal line in parts, and when, by the end of the song, she's dragging out the line "shut your eyes and breathe" a fraction of a beat behind the instrumentals, you feel like she's earned the ability to urge you to do something.
Second, you crank the tempo to make it fast enough to be danceable, or at least foot-tappable.
Third, you Disney the shit out of it. What does that mean? Well, the original was clean electric guitar and pretty standard four-piece rock setup. But this is a song about being young and enjoying yourself when you go out on the biggest party night of the year--there's got to be a little joy to it. So it starts with tambourine and a bouncing piano behind the first verse (switching from guitar to piano allows the chorus to climb the scale with every chord change the way open-fingering guitar doesn't), then adds something each time it crosses the start-finish line: Backing vocals for the first chorus, bells for the second verse, organ (or the most disciplined woodwind section ever) on the second chorus. Brass on the bridge, saxophones on the third verse, and then everything comes together on the final repeated chorus.
It's light, it's fun, it's a little juvenile, and that's fine, because it sounds and feels like a Christmas song in the best ways, and without any of the overplayed, Korean War-vintage bullshit that usually comes from such music. It's a magnificent song, and I want to host a New Year's party just so I can play it for other people for six hours in a row.
Wednesday, December 10, 2014
The Top 20 Songs I'd Use to End a Movie Whose Last Shot Is a Zoom Out of a Couple Kissing on the Dance Floor at a Senior Prom
- "Stolen" by Dashboard Confessional
- "Never Let Me Go" by Florence + the Machine
- "Heroes" by Mark Bonilla and the Front 48
- "Blurry Nights" by Hayden ft. Lou Canon
- "You and Me" by Lifehouse
- "I'm on Fire" by Bruce Springsteen
- "Iris" by the Goo Goo Dolls
- "Motorcycle Drive By" by Third Eye Blind
- "If You Leave" by Nada Surf
- "Desire" by Mates of State
- "Collide" by Howie Day
- "Soco Amaretto Lime" by Brand New
- "Eternal Flame" by The Bangles
- "Falling Slowly" by Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova
- "Islands in the Stream" by Constantines and Feist
- "Duet" by Rachael Yamagata and Ray LaMontagne
- "It Will End in Disaster" by White Sea
- "The Story" by Brandy Carlile
- "I Won't Give Up" by Jason Mraz
- "My Sundown" by Jimmy Eat World
Tuesday, July 8, 2014
15 Songs I Really Want to Cover
I propose all musicians make a list of 12-15 songs they really want to cover. We compare lists, if lots match we get together & play a show.I think this is a stupendous idea. Here are mine, in no particular order.
— ruhee.js (@ruhee_) June 10, 2014
- "One More Try"-George Michael
I just really like George Michael is all. I'm currently working on a rockabilly cover of this one. - "Shake it Out"-Florence + The Machine
Or "Never Let Me Go" or "Cosmic Love" or "Dog Days are Over." I love Flo-Mo, but so much of the band's charm is wrapped up in Florence Welch's unique voice and the band's interesting instrumentation, with accordions and harps and so on. I'd like to hear a straightforward rock/power pop version of one of the hits. - "Valentine"-Old 97s
This is an extremely simple country/rock song that begs to be sung by three guys around a campfire. In a just world, every middle school band would cover this one instead of "Wonderwall." - "The Weekenders"-The Hold Steady
I'm not a The Hold Steady fan at all. I tried as hard as I could to get into them, but nothing took, except this song. It's kinetic, it's got momentum, and I love love love singing along with it. My favorite song lyrics sound like prose that just happen to fit a rhythmic structure, and this song does that so well. You just get to the chorus and it feels like you're running down a steep hill and the vocal track is dragging you, like gravity, slightly faster than you want to go. - "Amie"-Damien Rice
I'm an extremely sad person, and I consume music and fiction in large part so I can experience sadness through other people's eyes and feel pain through the lens of other people's experience. It's comforting to know that I'm not the only person who wakes up and often as not wants to lock himself outside in the snow and sit there until I freeze to death. It's why I like The National and Elliott Smith and Graham Greene and Richard Ford.
Anyway, this is a very sad, very pretty song with a very nice violin part, and I like it a lot. - "Islands in the Stream"-Kenny Rogers and Dolly Parton
All I want in life is for someone to sing this with me at karaoke. If I weren't married already, I'd marry the woman who'd sing the Dolly Parton part with me at karaoke. - "Give It To Me"-Timbaland ft. Nelly Furtado and Justin Timberlake
All the backing parts are so simple, the vocals are fun--it's just a perfectly-constructed piece of danceable music. I bet a below-average four-piece band could arrange and learn a cover within two hours and turn any venue they play into a sex cave the same night. - "Hang Me Up to Dry"-Cold War Kids
I adore this song. I love that it's entirely unsubtle. I love that it's an extended metaphor about laundry and heartbreak. I love that it sounds like you could play it with construction equipment after consuming half a case of Schlitz. I want to get on a stage with a group of people and just jackhammer the shit out of this song. - "Peace of Mind"-Boston
This is the dream. If I practiced guitar nonstop for about three years, I bet it would be unimaginably fun to start a Boston cover band. - "Alone"-Heart
I love a good power ballad, and this is one of the best. Glee (I know, I know, but bear with me) did this really well as a duet once upon a time, and all it made me want to do was find some absolute diva of a lady vocalist and construct a band around her. - "Thunder Road"-Bruce Springsteen
Or "Born to Run" or "Badlands" or "I'm Going Down" or any more standard Springsteen song. I'm from New Jersey and I'm a sportswriter so I can't help it. - "Sweet Escape"-Gwen Stefani ft. Akon
This is a pop song that translates really, really well to a five-piece rock band. The rhythm guitar part and vocals play well enough together on their own that I bet this would work as an acoustic solo bit, but get a good drummer and a good guitarist and the cover could grow beyond the original boundaries of the song. - "I'll Believe in Anything"-Wolf Parade
Change the keyboards to accordion or distorted guitar, pick up the tempo a little bit...I love the lyrics and the shift from 3/4 to 4/4 at the end. - "The Good Life"-Weezer
My favorite genre of music is power pop, and Weezer is the best, or at least most, power pop band of the past 20 years. This could be any one of a dozen songs from the Blue Album or Pinkerton, but "The Good Life" features a chorus that allows you to really relish saying "shakin' booty," which I think is important in a cover set. - "The Fallen"-Franz Ferdinand
The band I was in in college toyed with this one for a while, but we never put it together for a show. I love the back-and-forth of the guitar parts, the relentless drive of the bass and the up-and-at-'em vocals. I don't know if it'd be particularly popular with an audience, but I bet this song is fun as hell to play live.
Sunday, January 26, 2014
Twenty-Seven Points on "Burning Down The House" by The Cardigans and Tom Jones
I'm a big Talking Heads fan. Well, I say that, but Talking Heads are the kind of band that inspires weird levels of devotion, so let me walk that back. I like Talking Heads a lot.
I also like The Cardigans. And by "I like The Cardigans," I mean what you'd expect me to mean--I love "Lovefool" and whenever it comes on I immediately turn into a drunk sorority girl, complete with leaning-in-to-belt-out-the-chorus and the "WOOHOO" with your drink hand in the air. But I don't know any of the Swedish mid-90s pop giants' other work. I assume they're the historical bridge between ABBA and Robyn, and nobody's ever going to tell me different.
So imagine my shock when I discovered this:
I wasn't even expecting to find this. It came up on my sidebar while I was watching the video for Willy Moon's "Get Up (What You Need)," which, while being a very cool song that makes me want to go run up a mountain like I'm in a Nike commercial, has next to nothing to do with Talking Heads, Tom Jones or The Cardigans.
But find it I did. And my heart made the noise that a jar of pickles makes when you open it for the first time and break the seal. Given my adoration not only for the principals involved in this...thing...but for cover versions of familiar songs, here are 27 points on "Burning Down The House" by The Cardigans and Tom Jones.
I also like The Cardigans. And by "I like The Cardigans," I mean what you'd expect me to mean--I love "Lovefool" and whenever it comes on I immediately turn into a drunk sorority girl, complete with leaning-in-to-belt-out-the-chorus and the "WOOHOO" with your drink hand in the air. But I don't know any of the Swedish mid-90s pop giants' other work. I assume they're the historical bridge between ABBA and Robyn, and nobody's ever going to tell me different.
So imagine my shock when I discovered this:
I wasn't even expecting to find this. It came up on my sidebar while I was watching the video for Willy Moon's "Get Up (What You Need)," which, while being a very cool song that makes me want to go run up a mountain like I'm in a Nike commercial, has next to nothing to do with Talking Heads, Tom Jones or The Cardigans.
But find it I did. And my heart made the noise that a jar of pickles makes when you open it for the first time and break the seal. Given my adoration not only for the principals involved in this...thing...but for cover versions of familiar songs, here are 27 points on "Burning Down The House" by The Cardigans and Tom Jones.
- Given that this is a live performance and I'd never heard this version of the song before, I'd assumed that this was a one-off tribute performance of some kind, like CHVRCHES' Janelle Monae cover. Not so. This was on an album, back in 1999. Reload s...holy crap. This might be the least absurd cover on the whole album.
- No, seriously. Fine Young Cannibals' "She Drives Me Crazy," by Tom Jones and something called Zucchero. This is like Mark Ronson's Version, except it's the direct-to-video remake starring Eric Balfour and James Remar. We are down the rabbit hole, my friends.
- I wonder if, since this was released as a radio single, there's a music video.
- There is. It takes place on a holodeck with a bunch of backup dancers who are either computer-generated or wearing mylar bodysuits or both.
- An underrated weird part of this cover is that if you told me beforehand that if these two artists had covered this song in 1999, this is exactly how I'd expect it to sound.
- That's what I'd expect after I slapped you in the face and called a witch doctor to cleanse my home of evil spirits, because I'm still not entirely comfortable living in a world where this song exists.
- I've been listening to David Byrne sing these lyrics for more than a decade now, and it's impossible to overstate how much easier Nina Persson and Tom Jones are to understand than David Byrne.
- That's even more shocking when you consider that Persson's not a native English-speaker. Jones is Welsh, so he only kinda speaks English, you know what I mean?
- Finding out Tom Jones is Welsh was more shocking than I'd expected it to be.
- Tom Jones looks like Bruce Springsteen would if he went to Bruce Jenner's plastic surgeon.
- I don't care how overproduced her voice is--I could listen to Nina Persson sing for ever and ever. I have a thing for smoky-eyed blondes with airy, vaguely nasally voices. I don't know why. I do know that I kept watching Glee for a full season and a half after it stopped being good, in large part because I am desperately and irretrievably in love with Dianna Agron. Like I almost went to see I Am Number Four in theaters. It's that bad.
- Now for the real kicker. If you haven't watched the live video yet, do. Because I have never seen more brazen and embarrassing lip-syncing than I'm seeing out of Nina Persson.
- A lot of the conspiratorially seductive appeal of "Lovefool" has to do with the effects on Persson's voice in that song, which are replicated in "Burning Down the House." Which is cool, but this is a live performance. And maybe they're running her mic through an effects board, but she sings this note-for-note the same way in the studio version, the Top of the Pops performance I embedded above and a third performance, which features the band playing in front of a set made to resemble an actual burning house, because subtlety isn't something the do in Europe, apparently.
- Maybe she swallowed a Vocoder or something. But she's dancing around and the volume doesn't change at all based on how far her face is from the microphone. Nobody who has pitch control that good would record an album that makes her sound like a sexy robot.
- Nina Persson is a robot.
- That's gotta be at least moderately tough on the band, right? Knowing that they've got to be perfect, or else the vocal track's going to be off? Well done by The Cardigans there.
- But seriously, she's smiling and shit. How can you smile when you're lip-syncing and Tom Jones is over there working his ass off? Seriously--that man's going balls-out on this song. Does she just not feel shame?
- This is like a two and a half minute song, in which she spends at least 60 seconds standing there head-bobbing and smirking. And not in the middle of a three-hour concert. One song. Can you not actually sing for 90 seconds?
- And this is like her one job. This isn't like Spacehog, where the one guy's singing and playing that awesome bass riff in "In the Meantime" at the same time. This is the opposite of that--she is doing none of the interesting things in this performance instead of all of the interesting things.
- And look at Tom Jones, dancing himself into a flop sweat. There's a goddamn professional. That dude's old as hell, and you can't give even a noticeable fraction of the effort he's putting out?
- I looked it up--Jones was 59 when this single came out. Persson was 25.
- Tom Jones is the one the women throw their underwear at, right? He deserves all the underwear. No underwear for you, Nina Persson. Not until you do your share of the work.
- Maybe it's a good thing Tom Jones is putting all his energy into singing, because when he lip-syncs, he makes some terrifying faces. So much of that music video is right up in his face, and it's terrifying.
- He's got really scary blue eyes. Kris Bryant blue. Trent Cole eyes.
- He looks the White Walker version of Bob Gunton.
- You ever wonder how collaborations like this come together? I want a transcript of the conversation between Tom Jones' agent and The Cardigans' agent. Do you think he even knew who they were before they got to the studio?
- What do you think David Byrne thinks of this? Eh, who cares. David Byrne is an asshole anyway.
Sunday, December 22, 2013
Baumann's Top 8 Songs of 2013
I'm not a music guy anymore. I used to be, but no longer--I've had three great writing loves in my life: fiction, sports and music, and I can only do two of them at a time. So as of right now, I haven't written a song or picked up my electric guitar or clarinet in almost five years, and the days of seeking out new and interesting music on my own are pretty much over. That's why I'm only doing eight songs--I don't have an original take on 100, and six of the eight songs on this list I got directly from either Paul Boye or Dany Sloan anyway.
But I experience music differently, I think, from the people who spoonfeed it to me anymore--only three of these songs are on Paul's top 100, for instance, though an equal number are off albums that put a song on his list but were left off themselves. And rather than trying to know all about modern music, I've decided to figure out why I like a song, ideally to figure out objective criteria. That's the purpose of this site, which I haven't posted on since May.
Anyway, all these songs were released in 2013--the real No. 1 song of 2013 for me was unquestionably "Call Your Girlfriend" by Robyn, which I only found out about this spring, but actually came out in 2011. In descending order:
8) "Wait for Love" by St. Lucia, from When the Night
When the Night, in an insane music year, was my favorite full album, and this spot could as easily have gone to three or four other tracks from the record. "Wait for Love" is an exceptionally well-written pop-rock track that climbs not only dynamically but in pitch as well, ascending from a bomb-ass bass line to a chorus that's heavy on falsetto.
It starts with just the bass and some synthy ephemera, then adds in, piece by piece, one vocal part, keyboards, cymbals, and then just gets generally louder. If I'd written this song, the dynamic contrast would've been obnoxious, probably with a full beat of silence before the chorus, but the crescendo from the verse to the chorus isn't that pronounced, a "how-do-you-boil-a-frog" elision from mezzo piano to mezzo forte. And by the time you're in a minute in, you get hit with the song's real party piece, and after that point you've got to just kind of bob your head and tap your foot and hope you're not driving for the next two minutes and thirty seconds.
Because that's when you get the quarter note triplets.
I once tried to make a list of the elements that make a pop song catchy, and came up with a list of about 30 rhythmic and melodic figures, but quarter note triplets stood out. The quarter note triplets in this song--you get them with the synth in the prechorus, but they're more pronounced in the vocal melody of the chorus--take you out of the groove you've been sitting in and nudge you a little bit each time, then grab you by the lapels on your jacket and toss you onto the dance floor and all of a sudden you're wearing a lei and khaki shorts and drinking rum out of a coconut through a straw.
Then the chorus ends and we start the whole process over, but with different building blocks to the chorus, including some punchy backing vocals, and then, everything but the steady synth and the lead vocals cut out for three beats before the pickup notes to the chorus. If this were a Dr. John song, there'd be a huge glissando at this point.
That the band is named for a small Caribbean island nation would probably put you in mind of a tropical aesthetic even if they sounded like A Perfect Circle. But this song is the closest I've come to partying on the beach in 2013.
7) "Let Go" by RAC, ft. Kele and MNDR, from Don't Talk To
This is a lovely bit of techno-post-punk melancholia from some guy I'd never heard of with Kele Okereke of Bloc Pary and MNDR, who I'd last seen providing the lead vocals for "Bang Bang Bang" by Mark Ronson and the Business Intl. It's a very steady, very repetitive beat that allows Okereke to really sit back and stay within himself. Okereke's always had a tremendously emotionally evocative voice, but in songs like "Flux" and "I Still Remember," loud and high and unhappy turns a little shouty. His voice coupled to this song is everything I liked about old, sad Bloc Party, but less analog and more mellow.
You should also check out the video, which I wanted to embed here but couldn't. It's about an extremely good-looking man who resembles a young Ben Kingsley with a wonderful mustache, who struggles to deal with his girlfriend, who looks like a goth Keira Knightley and loves to eat people. I want to live in the way this video looks, and it probably makes me like this song more than I would otherwise.
But where "Wait for Love" is a tribute to quarter note triplets, "Let Go" is a tribute to giving you exactly as much music as you need and not one beat more. It's almost invitingly simple throughout, with a steady bass and drum line without, and Okereke sort of hip leans his vocals into the void they fill. Never loud, never fast, "Let Go" settles into a groove and lets you live there.
6) "The Wire" by Haim, from Days Are Gone
This is the best-written song of 2013, by a band that might as well have been created from a checklist of things I like: keyboard-heavy a chick rock/power pop group that goes about its business with an earnest archness. "The Wire" is Weezer by way of Pat Benatar, blending vocals from all three Haim sisters in the cheekiest breakup song I've heard in years.
Haim's been the subject of quite a bit of backlash, most of it deserved--they're twee, and weird, and the product of stage parents, and Danielle Haim is really not a very good singer at all. I don't know that I've heard a criticism of the band or its music that wasn't entirely valid, and yet this album was on repeat on my computer for most of the summer.
I like that the "I just couldn't take it / I tried hard not to fake it" melody brings you up to the top of the stairs to the chorus, then goes back down to the ground floor and takes you there again. I like the interchanging lead vocals--if your lead singer is the worst vocalist in the group, you might as well pull off some boy band-style handoffs along the way. I like how shamelessly heavy this song is on three-part harmonies. I like that the lyrics wouldn't be horribly out of place in a normal conversation and still fit with the rhythm and phrasing of the melody--not doing this is my biggest pet peeve in music, and the reason why the most outspoken homophobe can't possible hate RENT more than I do.
I like that they're totally cool with dropping the beat, and that the bridge has the strings and running chromatic triplets out of a mid-90s pop-rock ditty. This song is sophisticated, calculated and completely beguiling at the same time, and it's wonderful.
5) "Slipped" by The National, from Trouble Will Find Me
Most of The National's albums have one song that's slower, softer and sadder than the rest, and that song is pretty routinely my favorite track from that record. There's a time for music to be fun, but the music I love the most is sad music you listen to when you don't like yourself very much and want to like yourself even less than you do already. So in the tradition of "Runaway" and "90 Mile Water Wall," The National broke away from the polyrhythmic, higher-energy flirtations of the earlier tracks on the album, and went back to the place where I love them the most.
"Slipped" swells and rocks in its own way, and the lyrics are typically clever, but listening to this song is like getting dumped, walking out to the end of a jetty at sunset and just sitting there hoping the sea comes in and you get to feel nothing instead of sadness. It's beautiful and warm and desperate, and the line "It'll be summer in Dallas before you realize" will stick to your soul.
4) "Youth" by Daughter, from If You Leave
Five of the songs on this list came from albums that I was kind of lukewarm about. But "Youth" is the fusion of styles that I didn't realize I should've asked for. It's the rambling and swelling post-rock of Explosions in the Sky, complete with rapid-fire drums and ringing guitar parts. It's also the breathy, expansive vocals of Florence and the Machine and the desperate, accusatory tone of Deja Entendu-era Brand New. The end product, at least in this song, is the best of all three parts: dramatic, ambitious and heartfelt.
(And I'm breaking my own rule here--"Youth" was on 2013's If You Leave, but I prefer the version that was on the Daughter's 2011 EP The Wild Youth. Sorry.)
This is radio-friendly post rock, where the whispered laments of the first two verses really earn the concussive bass drum of the choruses, then in the third verse, lead singer Elena Tonra goes up the octave, while behind her a running cymbal roll and a buzzing guitar line build and build, like Fender trying to simulate what bees sound like. Of the eight songs listed here, this is the prettiest.
3) "Hey, Doreen" by Lucius, from Wildewoman
I was going to cap this list at five songs, but during the early stages of reading Paul's Top 100 list, I came across this track. The rest of the album I could take or leave, but holy shit is it hard to have more fun than listening to "Hey, Doreen." I was going to do a point-by-point explanation of the specific musical points that make it so enchanting, but I'll just say this: Imagine Fitz and the Tantrums had a loudmouth sister, and imagine that she crashed a Ferrari full of clowns through the front wall of your house. That's what this song is like.
2) "Song For Zula" by Phosphorescent, from Muchacho
I lied. I said sometime in August, I think, that "Song for Zula" was going to be my favorite song of 2013. And it's not. Sorry. It's close to perfect, though.
"Song for Zula" won me over with the first line: "Some say love is a burning thing / And it makes a fiery ring." The way this song twists the classic Johnny Cash line from its original form into the sequel: what happens when you fall in love and get your heart broken? The play on the Cash song is only the start of the lyrical cleverness. Love is a cage, a paralytic agent, an animal--all expressing betrayal and heartbreak after having been taken in by the facile love expressed in pop music.
"Song For Zula" is part of a running theme in songs on this list: it's a very, very simple song with one very strong asset (the lyrics, in this case) and all other components subdued and out of the way so they can't mess anything up.
The best argument for this song is just to go and read the lyrics as it plays, because the music gets across the kind of trapped, aching, disappointed feeling, but lines like "See, honey, I saw love / You see, it came to me / It put its face up to my face so I could see" drive home that feeling more than you might think when the poetry of a song is so often window dressing to the music. This is like country-and-western W.H. Auden. "Song For Zula" makes you want to feel what this man is feeling, not because it sounds particularly pleasant, but because the feeling is so beautifully and clearly laid out.
One last note--this is not mankind's first attempt at a long, melancholy song without a chorus. I remember experiencing Antlers' "Two" and Airborne Toxic Event's "Sometime Around Midnight" and thinking "Wow, this would be really cool if they ever went anywhere with the original theme." This is how you pull that off--you play just slightly with the melody and the dynamics and leave room for instrumental breaks. Just in case anyone was wondering.
1) "Blurry Nights" by Hayden ft. Lou Canon, from Us Alone
I spent my first four months or so with this song not realizing how good it was because I kept getting tripped up by the time signature changes in the chorus. I remember driving overnight from Madison to Columbus in May and spending a large portion of the state of Indiana going back over and over the chorus trying to count it out. In the meantime, I didn't enjoy it as much as I would later, and I think it was in the interim that I declared "Song For Zula" to be my favorite track of 2013.
Hayden is a Canadian dude who looks like my AP chemistry teacher from high school, and while I don't think any of his other songs were bad, necessarily, this one stands head and shoulders above the rest. It's a folksy duet about, essentially, a drunken one-night hookup. The chorus, which I'll reproduce here, involves the most relatable musical production of asking someone to go home with you: "I don't know how to do this / But will you leave with me right now / Nothing good could ever come from this / In the long run, but let's not dismiss / All the fun we could have tonight if we forget how we might / Feel in the morning light."
There's no real incredible melodic, harmonic or dynamic part to this song, and it's kind of drowsy and meandering, but for some reason I find it just profoundly charming. I'm a sucker for cheesy duets, and this is kind of like "Islands in the Stream" for people who drink weird coffee and wear mustaches.
The final note: Lou Canon's voice. I've got a Spotify playlist for songs by female singers who make the hair stand up on the back of my neck. And there's the occasional belting jazz voice and the occasional bawdy, sort of tavern wench aesthetic on the playlist, but Lou Canon's got a faint, airy voice that gives you the distinct impression of being breathed on, and I can't get enough of her. I'm blushing right now.
"Blurry Nights" makes me want to go out and fall disgustingly, fawningly in love with the first person I meet. You don't get to the emotional state that makes "Slipped" or "Song for Zula" or even "The Wire" possible without having been here first.
But I experience music differently, I think, from the people who spoonfeed it to me anymore--only three of these songs are on Paul's top 100, for instance, though an equal number are off albums that put a song on his list but were left off themselves. And rather than trying to know all about modern music, I've decided to figure out why I like a song, ideally to figure out objective criteria. That's the purpose of this site, which I haven't posted on since May.
Anyway, all these songs were released in 2013--the real No. 1 song of 2013 for me was unquestionably "Call Your Girlfriend" by Robyn, which I only found out about this spring, but actually came out in 2011. In descending order:
8) "Wait for Love" by St. Lucia, from When the Night
When the Night, in an insane music year, was my favorite full album, and this spot could as easily have gone to three or four other tracks from the record. "Wait for Love" is an exceptionally well-written pop-rock track that climbs not only dynamically but in pitch as well, ascending from a bomb-ass bass line to a chorus that's heavy on falsetto.
It starts with just the bass and some synthy ephemera, then adds in, piece by piece, one vocal part, keyboards, cymbals, and then just gets generally louder. If I'd written this song, the dynamic contrast would've been obnoxious, probably with a full beat of silence before the chorus, but the crescendo from the verse to the chorus isn't that pronounced, a "how-do-you-boil-a-frog" elision from mezzo piano to mezzo forte. And by the time you're in a minute in, you get hit with the song's real party piece, and after that point you've got to just kind of bob your head and tap your foot and hope you're not driving for the next two minutes and thirty seconds.
Because that's when you get the quarter note triplets.
I once tried to make a list of the elements that make a pop song catchy, and came up with a list of about 30 rhythmic and melodic figures, but quarter note triplets stood out. The quarter note triplets in this song--you get them with the synth in the prechorus, but they're more pronounced in the vocal melody of the chorus--take you out of the groove you've been sitting in and nudge you a little bit each time, then grab you by the lapels on your jacket and toss you onto the dance floor and all of a sudden you're wearing a lei and khaki shorts and drinking rum out of a coconut through a straw.
Then the chorus ends and we start the whole process over, but with different building blocks to the chorus, including some punchy backing vocals, and then, everything but the steady synth and the lead vocals cut out for three beats before the pickup notes to the chorus. If this were a Dr. John song, there'd be a huge glissando at this point.
That the band is named for a small Caribbean island nation would probably put you in mind of a tropical aesthetic even if they sounded like A Perfect Circle. But this song is the closest I've come to partying on the beach in 2013.
7) "Let Go" by RAC, ft. Kele and MNDR, from Don't Talk To
This is a lovely bit of techno-post-punk melancholia from some guy I'd never heard of with Kele Okereke of Bloc Pary and MNDR, who I'd last seen providing the lead vocals for "Bang Bang Bang" by Mark Ronson and the Business Intl. It's a very steady, very repetitive beat that allows Okereke to really sit back and stay within himself. Okereke's always had a tremendously emotionally evocative voice, but in songs like "Flux" and "I Still Remember," loud and high and unhappy turns a little shouty. His voice coupled to this song is everything I liked about old, sad Bloc Party, but less analog and more mellow.
You should also check out the video, which I wanted to embed here but couldn't. It's about an extremely good-looking man who resembles a young Ben Kingsley with a wonderful mustache, who struggles to deal with his girlfriend, who looks like a goth Keira Knightley and loves to eat people. I want to live in the way this video looks, and it probably makes me like this song more than I would otherwise.
But where "Wait for Love" is a tribute to quarter note triplets, "Let Go" is a tribute to giving you exactly as much music as you need and not one beat more. It's almost invitingly simple throughout, with a steady bass and drum line without, and Okereke sort of hip leans his vocals into the void they fill. Never loud, never fast, "Let Go" settles into a groove and lets you live there.
6) "The Wire" by Haim, from Days Are Gone
This is the best-written song of 2013, by a band that might as well have been created from a checklist of things I like: keyboard-heavy a chick rock/power pop group that goes about its business with an earnest archness. "The Wire" is Weezer by way of Pat Benatar, blending vocals from all three Haim sisters in the cheekiest breakup song I've heard in years.
Haim's been the subject of quite a bit of backlash, most of it deserved--they're twee, and weird, and the product of stage parents, and Danielle Haim is really not a very good singer at all. I don't know that I've heard a criticism of the band or its music that wasn't entirely valid, and yet this album was on repeat on my computer for most of the summer.
I like that the "I just couldn't take it / I tried hard not to fake it" melody brings you up to the top of the stairs to the chorus, then goes back down to the ground floor and takes you there again. I like the interchanging lead vocals--if your lead singer is the worst vocalist in the group, you might as well pull off some boy band-style handoffs along the way. I like how shamelessly heavy this song is on three-part harmonies. I like that the lyrics wouldn't be horribly out of place in a normal conversation and still fit with the rhythm and phrasing of the melody--not doing this is my biggest pet peeve in music, and the reason why the most outspoken homophobe can't possible hate RENT more than I do.
I like that they're totally cool with dropping the beat, and that the bridge has the strings and running chromatic triplets out of a mid-90s pop-rock ditty. This song is sophisticated, calculated and completely beguiling at the same time, and it's wonderful.
5) "Slipped" by The National, from Trouble Will Find Me
Most of The National's albums have one song that's slower, softer and sadder than the rest, and that song is pretty routinely my favorite track from that record. There's a time for music to be fun, but the music I love the most is sad music you listen to when you don't like yourself very much and want to like yourself even less than you do already. So in the tradition of "Runaway" and "90 Mile Water Wall," The National broke away from the polyrhythmic, higher-energy flirtations of the earlier tracks on the album, and went back to the place where I love them the most.
"Slipped" swells and rocks in its own way, and the lyrics are typically clever, but listening to this song is like getting dumped, walking out to the end of a jetty at sunset and just sitting there hoping the sea comes in and you get to feel nothing instead of sadness. It's beautiful and warm and desperate, and the line "It'll be summer in Dallas before you realize" will stick to your soul.
4) "Youth" by Daughter, from If You Leave
Five of the songs on this list came from albums that I was kind of lukewarm about. But "Youth" is the fusion of styles that I didn't realize I should've asked for. It's the rambling and swelling post-rock of Explosions in the Sky, complete with rapid-fire drums and ringing guitar parts. It's also the breathy, expansive vocals of Florence and the Machine and the desperate, accusatory tone of Deja Entendu-era Brand New. The end product, at least in this song, is the best of all three parts: dramatic, ambitious and heartfelt.
(And I'm breaking my own rule here--"Youth" was on 2013's If You Leave, but I prefer the version that was on the Daughter's 2011 EP The Wild Youth. Sorry.)
This is radio-friendly post rock, where the whispered laments of the first two verses really earn the concussive bass drum of the choruses, then in the third verse, lead singer Elena Tonra goes up the octave, while behind her a running cymbal roll and a buzzing guitar line build and build, like Fender trying to simulate what bees sound like. Of the eight songs listed here, this is the prettiest.
3) "Hey, Doreen" by Lucius, from Wildewoman
I was going to cap this list at five songs, but during the early stages of reading Paul's Top 100 list, I came across this track. The rest of the album I could take or leave, but holy shit is it hard to have more fun than listening to "Hey, Doreen." I was going to do a point-by-point explanation of the specific musical points that make it so enchanting, but I'll just say this: Imagine Fitz and the Tantrums had a loudmouth sister, and imagine that she crashed a Ferrari full of clowns through the front wall of your house. That's what this song is like.
2) "Song For Zula" by Phosphorescent, from Muchacho
I lied. I said sometime in August, I think, that "Song for Zula" was going to be my favorite song of 2013. And it's not. Sorry. It's close to perfect, though.
"Song for Zula" won me over with the first line: "Some say love is a burning thing / And it makes a fiery ring." The way this song twists the classic Johnny Cash line from its original form into the sequel: what happens when you fall in love and get your heart broken? The play on the Cash song is only the start of the lyrical cleverness. Love is a cage, a paralytic agent, an animal--all expressing betrayal and heartbreak after having been taken in by the facile love expressed in pop music.
"Song For Zula" is part of a running theme in songs on this list: it's a very, very simple song with one very strong asset (the lyrics, in this case) and all other components subdued and out of the way so they can't mess anything up.
The best argument for this song is just to go and read the lyrics as it plays, because the music gets across the kind of trapped, aching, disappointed feeling, but lines like "See, honey, I saw love / You see, it came to me / It put its face up to my face so I could see" drive home that feeling more than you might think when the poetry of a song is so often window dressing to the music. This is like country-and-western W.H. Auden. "Song For Zula" makes you want to feel what this man is feeling, not because it sounds particularly pleasant, but because the feeling is so beautifully and clearly laid out.
One last note--this is not mankind's first attempt at a long, melancholy song without a chorus. I remember experiencing Antlers' "Two" and Airborne Toxic Event's "Sometime Around Midnight" and thinking "Wow, this would be really cool if they ever went anywhere with the original theme." This is how you pull that off--you play just slightly with the melody and the dynamics and leave room for instrumental breaks. Just in case anyone was wondering.
1) "Blurry Nights" by Hayden ft. Lou Canon, from Us Alone
I spent my first four months or so with this song not realizing how good it was because I kept getting tripped up by the time signature changes in the chorus. I remember driving overnight from Madison to Columbus in May and spending a large portion of the state of Indiana going back over and over the chorus trying to count it out. In the meantime, I didn't enjoy it as much as I would later, and I think it was in the interim that I declared "Song For Zula" to be my favorite track of 2013.
Hayden is a Canadian dude who looks like my AP chemistry teacher from high school, and while I don't think any of his other songs were bad, necessarily, this one stands head and shoulders above the rest. It's a folksy duet about, essentially, a drunken one-night hookup. The chorus, which I'll reproduce here, involves the most relatable musical production of asking someone to go home with you: "I don't know how to do this / But will you leave with me right now / Nothing good could ever come from this / In the long run, but let's not dismiss / All the fun we could have tonight if we forget how we might / Feel in the morning light."
There's no real incredible melodic, harmonic or dynamic part to this song, and it's kind of drowsy and meandering, but for some reason I find it just profoundly charming. I'm a sucker for cheesy duets, and this is kind of like "Islands in the Stream" for people who drink weird coffee and wear mustaches.
The final note: Lou Canon's voice. I've got a Spotify playlist for songs by female singers who make the hair stand up on the back of my neck. And there's the occasional belting jazz voice and the occasional bawdy, sort of tavern wench aesthetic on the playlist, but Lou Canon's got a faint, airy voice that gives you the distinct impression of being breathed on, and I can't get enough of her. I'm blushing right now.
"Blurry Nights" makes me want to go out and fall disgustingly, fawningly in love with the first person I meet. You don't get to the emotional state that makes "Slipped" or "Song for Zula" or even "The Wire" possible without having been here first.
Thursday, September 12, 2013
Paul's Top 10 Decemberists Songs
So Stereogum released another top 10 list of songs by artist with which I'm intimately familiar, so naturally, I've got objections and corrections to make. Though this one isn't nearly as far a departure from my own preferences as their National list was earlier this year, there are still changes I'd like to see. So I'll make them!
The Decemberists can be a divisive band; their music isn't aggressive, but the very characteristics that can make them a novel and enjoyable listen are also the qualities that can turn other listeners off. Colin Meloy's distinctive vocals, bizarre instrumental arrangements, esoteric and hyper-educated lyrics can either combine to charm or push away, with little middle ground.
Luckily for me, my takeaway from that concoction is an adoring one - for the most part - and I've enjoyed listening to enough Decemberists material to try and put together my version of a top 10 list.
10. The Sporting Life
Album: Picaresque
A bouncy song about an emasculated athlete (it's never explicitly said, but I always imagined the protagonist a football player) who comes up short in a big spot on the field and the ripple effect of disappointment among those in attendance. From the lead's flighty girlfriend to his disenchanted father to frustrated coach, it's not the most true-to-sport song ever written (although it doesn't hold a candle to that line in The Postal Service's "Nothing Better." You know which one) but it captures the spirit of the scene in a fun way. Even if it's all at the expense of this crushed athlete.
9. This Is Why We Fight
Album: The King Is Dead
The Decemberists have made their mark on me with slower-paced anthems (we'll get to those), but this is a good example of a rallying cry done right. It's got a bit of heroic swagger to it in the first half, and then, after an instrumental interlude at about the three-minute mark, the song is stripped down to an acoustic guitar (and a single electric strum) before building back up, only to break down again into a (tamed) vocal war cry and accompanying drum raps. It's one of their finer uptempo moments.
8. The Bachelor and the Bride
Album: Her Majesty The Decemberists
To date, I'm still not 100 percent certain what the exact story of this song is. I understand it's about something of a troubled relationship - possibly even abusive - but the minutiae escape me even after 10 years. Normally, that'd be a detriment, but the exactness of the story takes a back seat to the way this song is structured and layered. Solemnly introduced with an acoustic guitar and the telling of a passed child, then joined by a traveling drum beat (a "carry on" mantra embodied in sound) and a morose synth backdrop. It's a bit heartbreaking to listen to sometimes.
7. Annan Water
Album: The Hazards of Love
The Hazards of Love is a failed concept album, a fantastical tale of love lost, redemptive rescue and (spoiler alert) Titanic-like end. It misses the mark in more places than I like, but where it manages to hit said mark most squarely is on this taken-out-of-context cut. It starts sharply when listened to solo (led in by the previous track's instrumentals) but otherwise stands well enough on its own even when taken out of the album's story. The basic gist is the story's protagonist is off to rescue his love from a captor, and is presented with a raging body of water standing between him and the way to her. The song is a plea to the river to calm enough to allow passage, with the promise of personal sacrifice in return for the favor. It's dark and exposes the end of the album's story before its time, but despite its strange pretenses (not uncommon in Decemberists songs) it manages to feel human and genuine, if a bit melodramatic.
6. The Engine Driver
Album: Picaresque
In the summer of 2006, I had a preposterous job. I worked in a cocoa powder processing plant in Swedesboro, NJ from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. The early start meant waking up around 4:30-4:45 a.m. to get ready before making the 35-40-minute drive south from my folks' place in Cherry Hill. On many of those drives, cruising through an empty 295 under a pre-dawn sky, I found myself playing this song through a tape cassette adapter plugged into my boxy Zen jukebox. Few songs have captured a mood so perfectly. At the same time, this is a song about personal comfort, an acknowledgment that what you are may not be perfect, but lovable just the same. And if someone doesn't like that? Tough shit for them, not you.
5. The Tain
Album: The Tain
This might be cheating, but it's my list so to hell with rules. The Tain is, in reality, five songs combined into one on a single EP. Five distinguishable movements: drunken seaside bar shanty that goes from swaying to aggressive; a rain-soaked travelogue that catches flight at points; a creepy, female-sung verse that sounds lifted from some nightmarish carnival; a thatched overcoat punk ballad that leads into some of the prettiest, most soaring sounds the band has ever recorded. It's a strange journey that rewards every full listen.
4. The Mariner's Revenge Song
Album: Picaresque
There may be no song that better captures the spirit of The Decemberists as they are most widely known than this, a sprawling dirge of a parable told by its lead to a pursued quarry within the stomach of a whale that has swallowed them both. Yeah, really. The story gives the backstory, the motive for the pursuit, and inspires a bit of a rooting interest in this vengeful man.
3. 16 Military Wives
Album: Picaresque
I tend to stay away from most politically-charged tunes, but there's something funny about the bitten-tongue patriotism in Meloy's lyrics here. It also doesn't hurt that it's absolutely one of the most fun songs of the band's to listen to. It takes its fair share of pokes at the national way of doing things that still manage to ring surprisingly true, eight and a half years after its release.
2. July, July!
Album: Castaways and Cutouts
Mixed like a modern-day Beatles remaster with percussion and acoustic strings in one ear and electric strings in another, this song manages to be sonically unique even when it features one of the more typical instrument arrangements for this band (drums, guitars, bass, keyboard; no calliope or accordion or any of that!). Bonus: this song really isn't very political, but the YouTube uploader here decided to affix a picture of a butterfly with "eScoailist" beneath it, and that's made the video's comments hysterical, naturally.
1. On the Bus Mall
Album: Picaresque
Stereogum and I agree. Rather easily the best song in their catalog, this song combines the best of the band's musicianship and songwriting with touching, heart-rending lyrics of two companions' life on the road. Much in the way Interpol's "Untitled" kicks off Turn On the Bright Lights with music that defines its environment, that atmosphere of the companions' world here is set early: the empty, windy, rain-soaked street feeling carries in from the end of "Engine Driver" and lingers, lacing Meloy's lyrics with a dark night feeling that's simultaneously shiver-inducing and reminiscent of the warm blanket feeling you get while trying to avoid such things. It's beautifully done.
The Decemberists can be a divisive band; their music isn't aggressive, but the very characteristics that can make them a novel and enjoyable listen are also the qualities that can turn other listeners off. Colin Meloy's distinctive vocals, bizarre instrumental arrangements, esoteric and hyper-educated lyrics can either combine to charm or push away, with little middle ground.
Luckily for me, my takeaway from that concoction is an adoring one - for the most part - and I've enjoyed listening to enough Decemberists material to try and put together my version of a top 10 list.
10. The Sporting Life
Album: Picaresque
A bouncy song about an emasculated athlete (it's never explicitly said, but I always imagined the protagonist a football player) who comes up short in a big spot on the field and the ripple effect of disappointment among those in attendance. From the lead's flighty girlfriend to his disenchanted father to frustrated coach, it's not the most true-to-sport song ever written (although it doesn't hold a candle to that line in The Postal Service's "Nothing Better." You know which one) but it captures the spirit of the scene in a fun way. Even if it's all at the expense of this crushed athlete.
9. This Is Why We Fight
Album: The King Is Dead
The Decemberists have made their mark on me with slower-paced anthems (we'll get to those), but this is a good example of a rallying cry done right. It's got a bit of heroic swagger to it in the first half, and then, after an instrumental interlude at about the three-minute mark, the song is stripped down to an acoustic guitar (and a single electric strum) before building back up, only to break down again into a (tamed) vocal war cry and accompanying drum raps. It's one of their finer uptempo moments.
8. The Bachelor and the Bride
Album: Her Majesty The Decemberists
To date, I'm still not 100 percent certain what the exact story of this song is. I understand it's about something of a troubled relationship - possibly even abusive - but the minutiae escape me even after 10 years. Normally, that'd be a detriment, but the exactness of the story takes a back seat to the way this song is structured and layered. Solemnly introduced with an acoustic guitar and the telling of a passed child, then joined by a traveling drum beat (a "carry on" mantra embodied in sound) and a morose synth backdrop. It's a bit heartbreaking to listen to sometimes.
7. Annan Water
Album: The Hazards of Love
The Hazards of Love is a failed concept album, a fantastical tale of love lost, redemptive rescue and (spoiler alert) Titanic-like end. It misses the mark in more places than I like, but where it manages to hit said mark most squarely is on this taken-out-of-context cut. It starts sharply when listened to solo (led in by the previous track's instrumentals) but otherwise stands well enough on its own even when taken out of the album's story. The basic gist is the story's protagonist is off to rescue his love from a captor, and is presented with a raging body of water standing between him and the way to her. The song is a plea to the river to calm enough to allow passage, with the promise of personal sacrifice in return for the favor. It's dark and exposes the end of the album's story before its time, but despite its strange pretenses (not uncommon in Decemberists songs) it manages to feel human and genuine, if a bit melodramatic.
6. The Engine Driver
Album: Picaresque
In the summer of 2006, I had a preposterous job. I worked in a cocoa powder processing plant in Swedesboro, NJ from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. The early start meant waking up around 4:30-4:45 a.m. to get ready before making the 35-40-minute drive south from my folks' place in Cherry Hill. On many of those drives, cruising through an empty 295 under a pre-dawn sky, I found myself playing this song through a tape cassette adapter plugged into my boxy Zen jukebox. Few songs have captured a mood so perfectly. At the same time, this is a song about personal comfort, an acknowledgment that what you are may not be perfect, but lovable just the same. And if someone doesn't like that? Tough shit for them, not you.
5. The Tain
Album: The Tain
This might be cheating, but it's my list so to hell with rules. The Tain is, in reality, five songs combined into one on a single EP. Five distinguishable movements: drunken seaside bar shanty that goes from swaying to aggressive; a rain-soaked travelogue that catches flight at points; a creepy, female-sung verse that sounds lifted from some nightmarish carnival; a thatched overcoat punk ballad that leads into some of the prettiest, most soaring sounds the band has ever recorded. It's a strange journey that rewards every full listen.
4. The Mariner's Revenge Song
Album: Picaresque
There may be no song that better captures the spirit of The Decemberists as they are most widely known than this, a sprawling dirge of a parable told by its lead to a pursued quarry within the stomach of a whale that has swallowed them both. Yeah, really. The story gives the backstory, the motive for the pursuit, and inspires a bit of a rooting interest in this vengeful man.
3. 16 Military Wives
Album: Picaresque
I tend to stay away from most politically-charged tunes, but there's something funny about the bitten-tongue patriotism in Meloy's lyrics here. It also doesn't hurt that it's absolutely one of the most fun songs of the band's to listen to. It takes its fair share of pokes at the national way of doing things that still manage to ring surprisingly true, eight and a half years after its release.
2. July, July!
Album: Castaways and Cutouts
Mixed like a modern-day Beatles remaster with percussion and acoustic strings in one ear and electric strings in another, this song manages to be sonically unique even when it features one of the more typical instrument arrangements for this band (drums, guitars, bass, keyboard; no calliope or accordion or any of that!). Bonus: this song really isn't very political, but the YouTube uploader here decided to affix a picture of a butterfly with "eScoailist" beneath it, and that's made the video's comments hysterical, naturally.
1. On the Bus Mall
Album: Picaresque
Stereogum and I agree. Rather easily the best song in their catalog, this song combines the best of the band's musicianship and songwriting with touching, heart-rending lyrics of two companions' life on the road. Much in the way Interpol's "Untitled" kicks off Turn On the Bright Lights with music that defines its environment, that atmosphere of the companions' world here is set early: the empty, windy, rain-soaked street feeling carries in from the end of "Engine Driver" and lingers, lacing Meloy's lyrics with a dark night feeling that's simultaneously shiver-inducing and reminiscent of the warm blanket feeling you get while trying to avoid such things. It's beautifully done.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)